Why is the Michigan GOP holding a primary and a caucus?
Changes to the primary calendar result in a two-part nominating contest for the Michigan GOP amid intra-party turmoil
The Civic Listening Corps was formed in January 2022 to give communities across the country the tools and training needed to identify and fight the misinformation we see online every day. Our goal is to use the knowledge we gather together to prevent further attempts to undermine our civic discourse.
By subscribing to our reports, sharing this post, or directing your friends and family to civiclistening.org, YOU can make a difference against the spread of online misinformation.
When will Michigan vote for presidential nominees? Are the parties holding elections on the same day?
Michigan Presidential Primary, both parties: February 27, 2024
Michigan Republican Party Congressional Caucus Convention: March 2, 2024
Why is the Michigan GOP holding a primary and a caucus?
The Michigan GOP is holding both a primary and a caucus this year due to a change to the primary calendar made by the Democratic-led state legislature. The primary — set for Tuesday, February 27 — allows all voters to participate and will determine how 16 delegates are awarded. Typically, the Republican National Committee rules discourage states from “jumping to the front of the primary line without party permission, which would have penalized the state party for awarding delegates from any election before March 1,” according to local reporting by Bridge Michigan.
However, with the RNC’s blessing, given this change, the Michigan GOP plans to run a hybrid plan which includes a second date of March 2 for a caucus convention. This race will “allocate 39 out of [Michigan’s] 55 presidential delegates based on the results of 13 separate congressional district caucus meetings.”
According to the AP, in Michigan, “any registered voter…may participate in either primary. Michigan does not register voters by party. Voters will be asked to indicate in writing which party’s primary they wish to participate in, and the choice is recorded.” Conversely, “[f]or the March 2 GOP district conventions, only about 2,000 precinct delegates elected in the August 2022 state primary may participate.”
Who currently leads the Michigan GOP?
There are two people in Michigan GOP leadership currently dueling for legitimacy: Kristina Karamo and Pete Hoekstra. As NBC News reported, Karamo “has served as state party chair since February 2023,” but has fallen out of favor due to her fundraising and financial decisions and was voted out of power and replaced by Hoekstra who was recognized by the RNC as the chairman.
‘The issue is that Karamo has refused to step down unless met with legal action because she believes the vote was illegitimate. The Republican National Committee has intervened to settle the leadership dispute within the Michigan GOP, recognizing Pete Hoekstra as the chairman. Despite this, Kristina Karamo, who claims to be the rightful leader, refuses to concede. The state GOP is facing challenges in organizing the upcoming caucus on March 2, following the primary on February 27. The leadership conflict raises concerns about potential confusion among voters regarding the nominating process. However, both Karamo and Hoekstra say they believe they can overcome these challenges and ensure effective communication with voters. Former Michigan GOP Chair Saul Anuzis, interviewed by NBC News, said the dispute is unlikely to affect the outcome of the state’s nominating contest, though it could impact the delegate selection process.
What kind of problems could this lead to?
The confusion stemming from the ongoing dispute over the leadership of the Michigan GOP has the potential to cause several issues. First, it may lead to confusion among voters regarding the organization and execution of the nominating process, particularly the upcoming caucus following the primary. This confusion could result in lower voter turnout as individuals may need clarification about where, when, and how to participate in the electoral process.
While there is a possibility that the leadership dispute could escalate into a fight over delegate allocation, resulting in wider problems, this scenario is deemed less likely given the current lack of competition in the political landscape. Nonetheless, the uncertainty surrounding party leadership could still have detrimental effects on voter participation and confidence in the electoral process.
Where can I get more information about how and when to vote?
For more information about the logistics of the Michigan Primary, check out these sources:
How to vote and when to do it: A Michigan primary primer, from MLive
KNOW YOUR VOTING RIGHTS: February 2024 Presidential Primary Edition, from MichiganVoting.org
I understand that unless a judge steps in to resolve the GOP leadership issue, there will be two caucus sites on Saturday, one in Detroit (Karamo) and the other on the other side of the state, in Grand Rapids (Hoekstra). Thank you CLC for some clarification on the issue! Hopefully there won't be too much confusion among voters, especially lasting confusion.